You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
This is a documentation bug in the security-sensitive API — the risk is that integrators rely on this claimed capability
Current behavior
verify_attestation(token)
→ docstring claims: "Verifies a sender's JWT signature for a given message payload"
→ actual: verifies token was signed by THIS interceptor, no sender or payload context
→ misleading
Expected behavior
Docstring must accurately describe what the method does:
verify_attestation(token)
→ docstring: "Verifies that a JWT attestation token was issued by this interceptor instance.
Validates signature, expiration, and required claims (iss, sub, iat, exp, jti).
Returns (True, claims, None) if the token is valid and not expired."
→ no false claims about sender verification or payload binding
Or, if the intent is to eventually add sender signature verification here, the docstring should clearly say "NOT YET IMPLEMENTED."
Files to change
src/qwed_a2a/security/crypto.py:156 — correct the verify_attestation() docstring
Acceptance criteria
Docstring accurately describes what the method actually does
No mention of "sender's JWT signature" or "given message payload"
If the method remains context-free, document this limitation explicitly
Audit Finding — New (cross-references existing #19)
What's happening
crypto.py:156contains a docstring on theverify_attestationmethod that is factually wrong:The method:
token: stronly, with no payload or context parameterWhy this matters
This docstring creates a false trust signal in the code itself:
verify_attestation()verifies message sender signaturesAgentMessage.signaturefield being unverified), this is about the crypto API itself claiming it verifies something it doesn'tCurrent behavior
Expected behavior
Docstring must accurately describe what the method does:
Or, if the intent is to eventually add sender signature verification here, the docstring should clearly say "NOT YET IMPLEMENTED."
Files to change
src/qwed_a2a/security/crypto.py:156— correct theverify_attestation()docstringAcceptance criteria