Skip to content

Commit e7ffe42

Browse files
committed
docs: remove marketing language from SEA update review
- Remove subjective qualifiers like "excellent" and "production-ready" - Use direct technical descriptions - Remove emoji-heavy formatting in conclusion - Remove attribution
1 parent b3ff207 commit e7ffe42

File tree

1 file changed

+13
-20
lines changed

1 file changed

+13
-20
lines changed

docs/SEA_UPDATE_REVIEW.md

Lines changed: 13 additions & 20 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
22

33
## Executive Summary
44

5-
The SEA (Single Executable Application) self-update functionality is **production-ready** with excellent architecture and error handling. This document reviews the implementation, validates design decisions, and suggests minor enhancements.
5+
This document reviews the SEA (Single Executable Application) self-update implementation, validates design decisions, and suggests enhancements.
66

77
**Related Documentation**:
88
- See [`SEA_BOOTSTRAP.md`](./SEA_BOOTSTRAP.md) for bootstrap architecture and install flow
@@ -568,35 +568,28 @@ describe('self-update integration', () => {
568568

569569
## Conclusion
570570

571-
**Status**: **Production Ready**
571+
**Status**: Production Ready
572572

573-
The SEA self-update implementation is **excellent** with:
574-
- ✅ Solid architecture (multi-stage pipeline)
575-
- ✅ Proper error handling (rollback support)
576-
- Safe file operations (uses registry's `remove()`)
577-
- Platform-specific handling (Windows, macOS, Linux)
578-
- ✅ Good UX (dry-run, helpful errors, backup notifications)
573+
The SEA self-update implementation provides:
574+
- Multi-stage pipeline architecture
575+
- Error handling with rollback support
576+
- Safe file operations (uses registry's `remove()`)
577+
- Platform-specific handling (Windows, macOS, Linux)
578+
- Dry-run support and backup notifications
579579

580-
**Minor Enhancements**:
581-
- 🟡 Add checksum verification (requires release process changes)
582-
- 🟡 Add progress indicators (better UX for large downloads)
583-
- 🟡 Add retry logic (more reliable on poor networks)
584-
- 🔵 Add backup rotation (disk space management)
580+
**Potential Enhancements**:
581+
- Add checksum verification (requires release process changes)
582+
- Add progress indicators
583+
- Add retry logic
584+
- Add backup rotation (disk space management)
585585

586586
**Next Steps**:
587587
1. Add checksums to GitHub release artifacts
588588
2. Implement progress indicators
589589
3. Add retry logic with exponential backoff
590590
4. Add integration tests
591591

592-
**Confidence Level**: 🟢 **High**
593-
- Architecture is sound
594-
- Error handling is comprehensive
595-
- Code quality is excellent
596-
- Ready for production use
597-
598592
---
599593

600594
*Document created: 2025-10-04*
601595
*Last updated: 2025-10-04*
602-
*Author: Claude Code*

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)