Settings - "Reviewing" & Deck import do not handle SchedV1 correctly

[david-allison]

Checked for duplicates?

• This issue is not a duplicate

Does it also happen in the desktop version?

• This bug does not occur in the latest version of Anki Desktop

What are the steps to reproduce this bug?

• replace your collection with this colpkg: .zip
• Settings - Reviewing
• 3 dialogs appear, all looking identical, so it looks like dismissing doesn't work

Expected behaviour

A dialog like this:

Debug info

AnkiDroid Version = 2.21alpha7-debug (e8a464e59ac387c7e154d0fb16a0222e0f48944d)
Backend Version = 0.1.48-anki24.11 (24.11 c47638ca36f99dd4f3b81ae82d964aec66e392e0)
Android Version = 9 (SDK 28)
ProductFlavor = amazon
Device Info = unknown | Android | generic_arm64 | sdk_gphone_arm64 | Android SDK built for arm64 | ranchu
Webview User Agent = Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 9; Android SDK built for arm64 Build/PSR1.210301.009.B1; wv) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Chrome/94.0.4606.71 Mobile Safari/537.36
ACRA UUID = 9ee8f6b3-3baf-4059-9681-be5eaca8a300
FSRS = 1.4.3 (Enabled: false)
Crash Reports Enabled = false

(Optional) Anything else you want to share?

No response

Research

• I have checked the manual and the FAQ and could not find a solution to my issue
• (Optional) I have confirmed the issue is not resolved in the latest alpha release (instructions)

[david-allison]

I've seen this one a few times in reviews for 2.19. @mikehardy would you support a backport for a [probably simple] fix, since we've done a huge upgrade for some users with:

• Releases supporting lower minSdk versions not retained in Play Store #17791

[snowtimeglass]

@david-allison

"Reviewing" & Deck import do not handle SchedV2 correctly

I may be misreading what you mean, but at the moment the title looks misleading or incorrect to me. If I understand correctly, the error occurs just when users' collections are using V1 scheduler, not V2 scheduler. Do you have a different view on this point?

[david-allison]

@snowtimeglass no, fair point. Title updated

EDIT: Just confirmed. It's SchedV1

[mikehardy]

I would definitely take a backport if it was reasonable at all, as a set of commit picks

[mikehardy]

For what it's worth, user reports that you can create a new deck, then press on the deck, and that will update things? I'm not 100% clear on that, and I have not tested it personally - just saying that there is a report of success getting a v1 collection back to usability on 2.19...

Obviously a real fix here would be preferable 😆

[david-allison]

This issue is specifically for errors on the 'Reviewing' and 'Deck Import', which do not offer a path to upgrade.

If the user has a reviewable deck, then they can click on that and the upgrade to V3 is offered.

If the user does not have decks, the UX of upgrading would be unlikely to lead to success

[snowtimeglass]

It may be desirable for UX to show the message without waiting for user tapping a deck, as in 1 below.

1. Just after starting the desktop version:
   

2. In case of ignoring the message above and then select a deck
   

[snowtimeglass]

For reference of AnkiDroid (2.21alpha7) behavior:

Record_2025-01-18-14-44-22_c428a0327e1e5e78cdd71c6b04816edf.mp4

[oyeraghib]

Hi, I want to help with this issue. Please assign if it is not taken.

[oyeraghib]

On clicking Stats in Anki this error comes up. Seems like the similar message upon pressing "Reviewing" in Ankidroid. It mentions the option "Learn More" but only gives "OK" as the option.

[david-allison]

Worth dropping a bug upstream for that one

[snowtimeglass]

On clicking Stats in Anki this error comes up. Seems like the similar message upon pressing "Reviewing" in Ankidroid. It mentions the option "Learn More" but only gives "OK" as the option.

Worth dropping a bug upstream for that one

In the desktop version, the error message can be interpreted that "Please select Learn More, which is already shown in the main screen, before proceeding". This flow may have room for improvement of UX, but not so much as a bug, in my opinion.

[oyeraghib]

On clicking Stats in Anki this error comes up. Seems like the similar message upon pressing "Reviewing" in Ankidroid. It mentions the option "Learn More" but only gives "OK" as the option.

Worth dropping a bug upstream for that one

In the desktop version, the error message can be interpreted that "Please select Learn More, which is already shown in the main screen, before proceeding". This flow may have room for improvement of UX, but not so much as a bug, in my opinion.

I think the same dialog which is prompted on the main screen should be prompted here instead of showing it as an error from backend.