copy-on-select = clipboard causes "Copied to clipboard" toast spam

[mitchellh]

Discussed in #4766

^{Originally posted by dumbasPL January 7, 2025}
host: Arch Linux, GNOME 47 on Wayland
version: 1.0.2-main+a3837a1e (built from source)
simplified config (without theming):

shell-integration-features = no-cursor
copy-on-select = clipboard
scrollback-limit = 134217728
adw-toolbar-style = raised-border
auto-update = off
term = xterm-256color

steps to reproduce:

1. enable copy-on-select = clipboard
2. select something by clicking and dragging the mouse
3. observe Copied to clipboard spam at the bottom

expected behavior:
Copied to clipboard shows once the selection has ended (when the mouse button is lifted)

Solution

I think we should also look into the core here (src/Surface.zig) to see if we should only apply the selection when a mouse release event happens.

We should probably also change the GTK implementation to only show the toast after a very short (50ms or so) delay.

[lcx]

this happens with MacOS as well, it's constantly copying to clipboard. When using something like alfred which has an option to merge clipboards if cmd+c is pressed twice, the result is very bizzare merging of multiple entries to the clipboard.
Turning this of in alfred still shows the multiple entries of the same data copied to clipboard in the clipboard history.

[gegoune]

I have enquired about this a while ago on discord. See link below for screenshot of what's described by @lcx above.

https://discord.com/channels/1005603569187160125/1313506853765779528

[JeffreyVdb]

This also means that when you're using a clipboard manager, the list of entries is going to get cluttered very quickly. A selection of 10 characters basically means that you'll have 10 entries in your clipboard manager, every subsequent entry being one character longer than the one preceding it. Your last entry will be the one you want but you'll quickly erase other clipboard entries unless your history is really big.

[otomist]

Going to take a shot at fixing this

[otomist]

I think we should also look into the core here (src/Surface.zig) to see if we should only apply the selection when a mouse release event happens.

For mouse release there's functionality for following links. Is it safe to assume that following links should take precedence?
Having both happen works too but my general thought is if someone is holding Ctrl they are probably looking to click a link and not copy text.

[jnichols0]

I've opened PR #5010 to fix the toast spam. @otomist sorry, didn't see you were looking at this til just now. If my implementation turns out to not be quite right, please feel free to take this on. :)

[mitchellh]

Pushing this out into 1.1.x since the fix requires a bit more work.

[desdic]

can the 'Copied to clipboard' be disabled completely ? I don't use Gnome but it still blocks the selected text for about 1-2s

[threddast]

I would also appreciate having an option to disable it, it does look out-of-place on non-Gnome

[mitchellh]

Yes you can: https://ghostty.org/docs/config/reference#app-notifications

[erhhung]

Coming from iTerm I rely on having the copy-on-select feature. I also use the handy Maccy clipboard utiliity on macOS that, like Alfred, keeps a list of copy buffers.

For a while, I thought I had mechanical mouse button glitches that would quickly obliterate half of my 50-entry Maccy history with near identical entries, then eventually figuring out that the clipboard events are generated each time the selection changes even while the mouse button was still held down.

This should be an easy thing to fix, no? Just trigger the copy event only on mouse up.

[pluiedev]

Unmarking as Linux-specific since this exists on macOS as well

[m-kru]

Any updates on this annoying "Copied to clipboard" spam?

[pluiedev]

Any updates on this annoying "Copied to clipboard" spam?

There's many linked PRs to this issue (e.g. #5995). As a matter of etiquette, please do not leave "any updates" or +1-style comments on issues in this repository.

[ciro-mota]

app-notifications = no-clipboard-copy - It did what I needed, which is just disabling this notification.