How to make repeated attempts with progressive delay?

[paulzi]

I want to make each retry attempt each time more delayed. However, I could not do it, because there is no delay property in ErrorEvent:

Yii::$app->queue->on(Queue::EVENT_AFTER_ERROR, function (ErrorEvent $event) {
    if ($event->job instanceof SomeJob) {
        //$event->delay = $event->attempt * 30; // there I want to set delay based on attempt
        $event->retry = $event->attempt < 5;
    }
});

It would also be nice to add in the RetryableJob method getRetryDelay:

public function getRetryDelay($attempt, $error)
{
    return $attempt * 30;
}

[pgyf]

I also encountered this problem #172

[dawnBefore]

+1
I use :

'on afterError' => function (\yii\queue\ErrorEvent $event) {
      $event->ttr = $event->attempt * 2;
},

but job log ttr: 2, 4, 8, 8, 8, 8.....

[paulzi]

As a temporary solution

class ProgressiveQueue extends yii\queue\db\Queue
{
    protected function reserve()
    {
        $payload = parent::reserve();
        $this->db->createCommand()->update($this->tableName,
            ['ttr' => $payload['ttr'] * 2],
            ['id' => $payload['id']]
        )->execute();
        return $payload;
    }
}

[metalagman]

+1 for the getRetryDelay

[lgXenos]

А воз и ныне там...

How to make repeated attempts with progressive delay?
Are you may add function getRetryDelay?

I use AMQP Interop, so example

$this->db->createCommand()

is unreal... as I think )

[futuster]

Ребята, можно же в симфони контрибьютить или в ларавель, зачем вы свои велосипеды делаете? С 2017 года элементарный вопрос не решен (как и 9000 других) рукалицо.жпг

Только учите плохому новичков, которые ваши велосипеды продают заказчикам, а потом всё это добро не понятно как поддерживать. Лучи ненависти.

[samdark]

@futuster уже бы давно сделали и послали pull request.