Skip to content

Add issue approval readiness checklist (#144) - #160

Merged
El-swaggerito merged 3 commits into
Raegis-RWA:mainfrom
d3vobed:main
Jul 29, 2026
Merged

Add issue approval readiness checklist (#144)#160
El-swaggerito merged 3 commits into
Raegis-RWA:mainfrom
d3vobed:main

Conversation

@d3vobed

@d3vobed d3vobed commented Jul 29, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Description

Creates an Issue Approval Readiness Checklist that contributors and reviewers can use before considering an issue ready for GrantFox evaluation. The checklist covers all key areas — implementation completeness, testing expectations, CI status, acceptance criteria review, documentation, and known limitations — and explicitly states that merged PRs are still subject to evaluation.

Closes: #144

Type of Change:

  • Bug fix
  • New feature
  • Breaking change
  • Documentation (changes to documentation only)
  • Refactor
  • CI/CD

Evidence Checklist

1. Issue Reference

2. Implementation Summary

  • A clear summary of what was changed and why is provided above
  • Files Changed:
    • docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md (new) — Pre-evaluation checklist with 6 sections: implementation completeness, testing expectations, CI status, acceptance criteria review, documentation, and known limitations. Includes a prominent "Merge ≠ Evaluation" disclaimer at the top and a self-review flow at the end
    • README.md (modified) — Added the new checklist to the key resources list, right after the evaluation-readiness index

3. Testing

  • Tests have been added or updated to cover the changes
  • All existing tests pass locally
  • If tests are not applicable, explain why:
    Documentation-only change — no testable logic was introduced. The new document is a Markdown checklist file.

Test Commands Run:

npm run lint
npm run build

Test Output (summary or screenshot):

Documentation-only change — all existing tests, lint, and build checks are unaffected.

4. Commands Run

  • The following commands were executed locally to validate the change:
npm run lint
npx tsc --noEmit
npm run build
npm test

5. CI Status

  • All CI checks will pass on this PR
  • No new warnings or errors were introduced
  • CI Pipeline Link (if available): N/A

6. Acceptance Criteria Coverage

  • All acceptance criteria from the linked issue have been satisfied
  • Criteria Mapping:
Acceptance Criterion Evidence File
Approval readiness checklist is added Full checklist document created with 6 sections covering all required areas docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md
Checklist states that merged PRs are still subject to evaluation Prominent "Important: Merge ≠ Evaluation" disclaimer at the top, referencing the Contributor Payment Guide docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md (line 11-13)
Testing expectations are included Section 2 "Testing Expectations" covers test coverage, passing tests, UI screenshots, and negative-path tests docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md (section 2)
CI status expectations are included Section 3 "CI Status" covers lint, type check, build, tests, and documenting resolved failures docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md (section 3)
Acceptance criteria review is included Section 4 "Acceptance Criteria Review" covers criteria-to-evidence mapping and PR traceability table docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md (section 4)
README links to the checklist New checklist added as the second entry in the key resources list under Contributing README.md

Screenshots / Recordings

N/A — documentation-only change.


Reviewer Notes

This checklist complements the existing Self-Assessment Checklist (for pre-submit use) and the Review Quality Checklist (for reviewers). It fills the gap between PR merge and GrantFox evaluation, giving contributors a clear final gate to pass before requesting payment review. All references link to existing docs.

iexwr added 2 commits July 29, 2026 01:00
- Create docs/evaluation-readiness-index.md (central index page linking
  to all evaluation-readiness requirements)
- Create docs/ci-guidance.md (CI pipeline steps, local checks, common fixes)
- Create docs/acceptance-criteria-audit.md (criteria-to-evidence mapping)
- Create docs/self-assessment-checklist.md (pre-submit review checklist)
- Update README.md to link to evaluation-readiness index from contrib resources
- Create docs/issue-approval-readiness-checklist.md covering:
  - Implementation completeness, testing expectations, CI status
  - Acceptance criteria review, documentation, known limitations
  - Merge != evaluation disclaimer referencing payment guide
  - Self-review flow for requesting GrantFox evaluation
- Update README.md to link to checklist from key resources
@El-swaggerito

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor
\nThis PR is currently blocked by merge conflicts.\n\nPlease update the branch with the latest main branch and resolve the conflicts before it can be merged.

@El-swaggerito

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor
\nGitHub has not finished calculating whether this PR can be merged cleanly.\n\nThe auto-merge automation will skip this PR for now. Re-run the automation later.

@d3vobed

d3vobed commented Jul 29, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

@El-swaggerito finish fix merge pr

@El-swaggerito
El-swaggerito merged commit 12bc61d into Raegis-RWA:main Jul 29, 2026
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants