Skip to content

Audit caller-aware access and free-tier signal shapes - #9

Draft
YE-YI7 wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
agent/catalog-pricing-rules
Draft

Audit caller-aware access and free-tier signal shapes#9
YE-YI7 wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
agent/catalog-pricing-rules

Conversation

@YE-YI7

@YE-YI7 YE-YI7 commented Aug 11, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

What changed

  • adds a deterministic audit over the 30 committed library manifests
  • records the audit result and decision-ready interpretation
  • adds a vendor-scoped candidate access extension for ai-catalog#83
  • models non-authoritative prices as priceEchoes[]
  • models compound allowances as freeTierRules[]
  • reserves an authenticated pricingResolver reference for caller-specific terms
  • validates all 30 candidate objects against a JSON Schema

Why

New feedback in Agent-Card/ai-catalog#83 identified two weaknesses in a scalar discovery price: negotiated caller-specific prices and compound free-tier limits. The audit measures those gaps against ASM's real library before proposing a WG-neutral namespace.

Headline findings:

  • 22/30 manifests advertise a free tier
  • only 8/22 have any allowance description
  • 0/22 have machine-readable free-tier rule sets
  • Perplexity already loses one of two positive price dimensions in the legacy cheapest-scalar projection
  • ATTOM has a concrete coarse-tier conflict: it derives as free while the manifest says production access is sales-led after a 30-day trial
  • six resolver candidates are a text-review queue, not six verified personalized contracts

This PR does not change ASM v0.3 or the live catalog projection. It keeps the candidate under an ASM-owned namespace until the WG chooses a neutral extension key.

Validation

  • python experiments/access_signal_shape_audit.py --pretty
  • independent jq recomputation of the headline counts
  • python -m pytest scorer/test_ai_catalog_access_extension.py -q — 3 passed
  • python -m pytest scorer -q — full Python suite passed
  • python -m compileall -q asm_access_extension.py experiments/access_signal_shape_audit.py
  • git diff --check

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant