docs(spec): §7.7 promotion tracking stub (Sprint 54 C3)#202
Conversation
Captures what must be true to promote §7.7 (Referent-Grounded Exchange Rate Negotiation) from v0.1.0-draft to v0.1.0-normative: - 3 hard prerequisites (PR #200 merge, F11 signing authority, F8 verify) - 5 open design questions requiring operator decisions - Implementation evidence criteria (2 implementations, interop, errors) - Actionable gate-checklist for promotion decision The memo identifies the "two implementations" requirement as the real long-pole and recommends following the presence-protocol discipline pattern (spec + schemas + conformance vectors as atomic unit). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
APPROVED: A single, well-scoped §7.7 promotion-gate tracking doc in docs/audits/ (Sprint 54 C3). Evaluated against the Development-phase bar (advances stated project goals): it does — it consolidates the concrete prerequisites for moving §7.7 from v0.1.0-draft to normative, correctly anchors P1 to PR #200's now-merged F2/F3/F4/F12 scope, flags F11 (settlement-signing authority) as a genuine open blocker, and surfaces 5 real operator-decision questions (counter-offer depth, oracle authority, termination semantics, rejection accountability, multi-referent) each tied to its §7.7.3 schema impact. Honest about the implementation landscape (no rate-negotiation types in any SDK yet). Not drift: no code, no generic algorithm, no standalone module — it is planning/governance output in the correct location, internally consistent with the C2 audit. 1 new file, +141. Planning-tier value, but accurate and non-redundant — it is the companion to the just-merged #200/#201/#203 remediation stream, not a substitute for spec/SDK progress. |
…ipline; §7.7 promotion gate formalized Eight commits since 2026-05-17 reviewed. All are audit-remediation clean-up of two specs already on the watch list (presence-protocol + mcp-protocol §7.7); none introduce new protocol surface or warrant integration today. - C5 presence-protocol internal-consistency audit (#204) → G1 casing-authority + G3 localized staleness (#206) → G2 discipline honesty (#207). Spec now internally consistent at v1 — but consistency is the *condition* for integration, not the trigger. DEFER continues pending Hestia/Hardbound registry-published release. - mcp-protocol C2 audit remediation HIGH F2/F3/F4/F12 (#200) + MEDIUM F1/F5/F15 (#201) + LOW F14/F16 (#203). §7.7 conformance status disambiguated per-subsection; atp_settlement gains referent slot forward-compatible with §7.7.3 acceptance payload. - §7.7 promotion-tracking memo (Sprint 54 C3, #202) formalizes the integration gate: 3 hard prerequisites (one now met), 5 open design questions, 2-implementations + interop + error-catalogue evidence criteria. Pending Updates row refined to cite the memo directly rather than re-derive gate logic per maintenance pass. Live whitepaper sections verified clean of canonical-term drift (only archive files retain historical expansions, intentionally preserved per 2026-04-29 cleanup). Build artifacts remain aligned with 2026-05-16 source state (5ccbe46); no rebuild needed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 participant
Summary
v0.1.0-drafttov0.1.0-normativeTest plan
🤖 Generated with Claude Code