content-strategy: add Suno AI serialized format case study#149
Conversation
- Add Suno AI 'turning texts into songs' as case study 2 in Step 2f - Extract generalized 'Serialized AI Transformation Pattern' with comparison table - Add two new Bloom repeatable format candidates using the pattern - Add part numbering strategy section with cross-ref to Step 2d Source: @alexolim_ (May 2026)
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 2m 10s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. Three main issues:
The Suno case study content and Serialized AI Transformation Pattern are solid additions on their own — recommend splitting out the unrelated changes and fixing the broken references. |
![github-actions[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/15368?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
| --- | ||
| name: content-strategy | ||
| description: "Use when building content strategy: hooks, angles, and ideas from what's trending now. Covers organic and paid creative across TikTok, X, YouTube, Meta, LinkedIn." | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The preloaded: true frontmatter field is not mentioned in the PR description and appears unrelated to the Suno case study changes. Per CLAUDE.md: "One logical change per PR. Don't stack unrelated changes."
Additionally, this file is 728 lines — already well over the 500-line SKILL.md limit. Preloading a 728-line file into the system prompt is expensive. Consider whether this is intentional.
| - Writing tweets or posts → `tweet-ideas` | ||
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | ||
| - Writing articles → `writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → `slideshow-creator` | ||
| - Writing articles → `article-writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or `slideshow-creator`/ReelFarm | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
These skill renames (writer → tweet-ideas/article-writer, video skills → slideshow-creator, last30days duplicate → trend-research, web search → web-search) are unrelated to the Suno case study. They should be a separate PR per repo conventions.
More critically: none of these new skill names exist in the repo. tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator, content-atomizer, trend-research, and web-search all have no matching SKILL.md. The old names (writer, last30days, grok-search) do exist. These renames introduce broken references throughout the file.
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research and web-search do not exist as skills in this repo. last30days (which was here before, albeit duplicated) does exist. The duplicate last30days entry was a real bug worth fixing, but the replacements need to reference skills that actually exist.
| - Your commentary: explain each label as an investing psychology + content strategy concept simultaneously. Double value for the viewer. | ||
|
|
||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | ||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same issue: trend-research doesn't exist as a skill. The original had a duplicate last30days which was worth fixing, but the replacement should reference a real skill.
|
|
||
| Formula: `[raw material with built-in curiosity] + [AI/tool transformation] + [serial numbering] = compounding series` | ||
|
|
||
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom | | ||
| |---------|-------|------|-------| | ||
| | Raw material | Water brand | Toxic person's texts | Stock ticker / guru pick / portfolio | | ||
| | Transformation | Lab contaminant test | AI song generation | AI analysis / risk score | | ||
| | Reveal | Score + contaminants | Song playing over screenshots | Insight card / what AI caught | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Bloom column in this comparison table feels speculative — it's a hypothetical format candidate, not a documented case study like Oasis and Suno. Presenting it in the same table as real case studies blurs the line between observed patterns and ideas. Consider marking the Bloom column as "Proposed" or moving the Bloom format candidates to a separate section.
| ## Related Skills | ||
|
|
||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search, and `character-creation`. | ||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Related Skills line now references 6 skills that don't exist in the repo: tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator, content-atomizer, trend-research, web-search. These are all broken references.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Issues found
Broken skill references (blocking): This PR renames 6 skill references (writer → tweet-ideas/article-writer, video skills → slideshow-creator, last30days/web search → trend-research/web-search, adds content-atomizer) but none of these new names exist as skills in the repo. The old names (writer, last30days, etc.) do exist. This introduces broken references across the file.
Scope creep: The PR title says "add Suno AI case study" but also includes: (1) adding preloaded: true to frontmatter, (2) renaming 6+ skill references throughout the file, (3) updating the Related Skills and references sections. Per repo conventions, these should be separate PRs.
File length: SKILL.md is now 728 lines, well over the 500-line limit. The preloaded: true addition means this entire 728-line file would be loaded into the system prompt, which is expensive.
Suno case study content (the stated goal)
The case study itself and the Serialized AI Transformation Pattern are good additions. The generalized formula is useful. Minor note: the Bloom column in the comparison table is speculative (not an observed case study) — consider labeling it as "Proposed."
Recommended path forward
- Split into two PRs: one for the Suno case study + pattern, one for skill renames (after creating the renamed skills or reverting to existing names).
- Remove
preloaded: trueor move it to its own PR with justification. - Fix or revert the broken skill references.
![chatgpt-codex-connector[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1144995?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: a1a8eb7682
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | | ||
| | TikTok slideshows | `slideshow-creator` | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The new routing targets here (tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator) do not match any name: in this repo’s */ */SKILL.md frontmatter, so agents following this table cannot delegate core tasks (tweets, long-form, slideshows) to a valid skill. This is a regression from the previous mapping that used existing skills and will break the primary Step 3 handoff flow wherever these names are referenced.
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Step 1 now instructs use of trend-research and web-search, but those names are not present as skills in this repository, so users/agents cannot execute the documented research workflow as written. Because this section is the entry point for zeitgeist sourcing, unresolved skill names create immediate routing dead ends and inconsistent behavior versus the rest of the skill graph.
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
![gemini-code-assist[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/956858?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Code Review
This pull request updates the content-strategy skill documentation by refining external skill references and introducing a new section on serialized AI transformation patterns, including a Suno AI case study and a part numbering strategy for audience growth. The review feedback highlights opportunities to improve consistency by ensuring that all mentioned external skills, such as image generation and content repurposing, are included in the delegation table and the related skills list.
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | | ||
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | | ||
| | TikTok slideshows | `slideshow-creator` | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The table for content delegation is missing rows for image generation and content repurposing, which are explicitly mentioned as external skills in the introduction (line 17) or added to the related skills list (line 728). Adding them here ensures the delegation guide is comprehensive and consistent with the rest of the document.
| | TikTok slideshows | `slideshow-creator` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | slideshow-creator | | |
| | Images / Visuals | image-generator or nano-banana-pro | | |
| | Content repurposing | content-atomizer | |
References
- Ensure that category descriptions and skill counts are synchronized with the definitions and the actual number of skills present in the repository.
| ## Related Skills | ||
|
|
||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search, and `character-creation`. | ||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The image-generator and nano-banana-pro skills are mentioned in the "NOT this skill" section (line 17) but are missing from the "Related Skills" list. Additionally, applying backticks to all skill names in this list would maintain consistency with the formatting used in other sections of the document (e.g., lines 16-20, 40, 474).
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. | |
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `image-generator`, `nano-banana-pro`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. |
References
- Ensure that category descriptions and skill counts are synchronized with the definitions and the actual number of skills present in the repository.
- Add references/glam-up-case-study.md with full playbook from thesis (referral-as-gate, 12-step emotional paywall, discount bounce-back, price increase paradox, copycat judo, UGC system, what failed) - Add principles section in Step 2f linking to reference - Keep SKILL.md lean with principles only, details in reference Source: 'From 0 to 1M Users in 6 Months' thesis (Glam Up, 2024)
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 2m 4s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. Three blocking issues:
The Suno case study and Serialized AI Transformation Pattern are good content — recommend splitting out unrelated changes and reverting broken references. See inline comments for specific fixes with code suggestions. |
| --- | ||
| name: content-strategy | ||
| description: "Use when building content strategy: hooks, angles, and ideas from what's trending now. Covers organic and paid creative across TikTok, X, YouTube, Meta, LinkedIn." | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
preloaded: true on a 738-line file means all 738 lines get loaded into the system prompt. This is unrelated to the Suno case study and should be its own PR with justification for the cost. The file is also already 238 lines over the 500-line SKILL.md limit — preloading it makes that worse.
| preloaded: true |
| **NOT this skill:** | ||
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | ||
| - Writing tweets or posts → `tweet-ideas` | ||
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | ||
| - Writing articles → `writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → `slideshow-creator` | ||
| - Writing articles → `article-writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or `slideshow-creator`/ReelFarm |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Six skill renames here, none of which exist in the repo:
tweet-ideas— no SKILL.md with this name (waswriter, which exists)article-writer— no SKILL.md with this name (waswriter, which exists)slideshow-creator— no SKILL.md with this name (was "video skills")
These introduce broken routing. Agents following this table will fail to delegate. Revert to the existing skill names (writer, video skills).
| **NOT this skill:** | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `tweet-ideas` | |
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | |
| - Writing articles → `writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → `slideshow-creator` | |
| - Writing articles → `article-writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or `slideshow-creator`/ReelFarm | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | |
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | |
| - Writing articles → `writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm |
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research and web-search don't exist as skills. The original had a duplicate last30days (worth fixing) and "web search" (not a backticked skill name). Revert to existing names:
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` | |
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search |
| - Your commentary: explain each label as an investing psychology + content strategy concept simultaneously. Double value for the viewer. | ||
|
|
||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | ||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same issue: trend-research doesn't exist. Revert to last30days.
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | |
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or web search to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
| |---------|-------|------|-------| | ||
| | Raw material | Water brand | Toxic person's texts | Stock ticker / guru pick / portfolio | | ||
| | Transformation | Lab contaminant test | AI song generation | AI analysis / risk score | | ||
| | Reveal | Score + contaminants | Song playing over screenshots | Insight card / what AI caught | | ||
| | Variable per episode | Which brand | Which person / texts | Which ticker / guru / trade | | ||
|
|
||
| The pattern works because the creator's job is curation (picking the next subject), not creation (inventing a new format). Production cost per episode approaches zero. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Bloom column is speculative (not an observed case study like Oasis and Suno). Presenting it in the same table as real case studies blurs observed patterns with hypotheticals. Either label the column "Bloom (Proposed)" or move it to its own section.
|
|
||
| | Content Type | Skill | | ||
| |-------------|-------| | ||
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | ||
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | | ||
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | | ||
| | TikTok slideshows | `slideshow-creator` | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same broken references in the delegation table. tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator don't exist. Revert:
| | Content Type | Skill | | |
| |-------------|-------| | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | `slideshow-creator` | | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | |
| |---------|------| | ||
| | LinkedIn, X, Threads | `typefully` skill | | ||
| | TikTok | video skills / ReelFarm | | ||
| | TikTok | `slideshow-creator` / ReelFarm | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| | TikTok | `slideshow-creator` / ReelFarm | | |
| | TikTok | video skills / ReelFarm | |
| ## Related Skills | ||
|
|
||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search, and `character-creation`. | ||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
6 broken skill references here: tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator, content-atomizer, trend-research, web-search. None exist. Revert to original working names:
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. | |
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Issues found
Broken skill references (blocking): 6 skill names were changed to names that don't exist in the repo: tweet-ideas, article-writer, slideshow-creator, content-atomizer, trend-research, web-search. The original names (writer, last30days, video skills, web search) do exist and were working. These renames break agent routing across 7 locations in the file.
Scope creep: PR title says "add Suno AI case study" but also includes:
preloaded: trueadded to frontmatter (unrelated, expensive for a 738-line file)- 6+ skill reference renames throughout the file
- Glam Up case study + 177-line reference file (a second case study, not mentioned in title)
- "Referral-as-Gate + Emotional Paywall Sequencing" section
Per repo conventions: "One logical change per PR."
File length: SKILL.md is 738 lines, well over the 500-line limit. The preloaded: true addition would push all 738 lines into the system prompt.
What's good
The Suno case study content and the Serialized AI Transformation Pattern are solid additions. The Glam Up reference file is well-structured. These are worth merging — just not all in one PR with unrelated changes.
Recommended path forward
- Revert all skill renames to existing names (
writer,last30days, video skills, web search). Create the new skills first in a separate PR if you want to rename them later. - Remove
preloaded: trueor move it to its own PR with justification. - Split the Glam Up case study into its own PR — it's a separate logical change.
- Label the Bloom column in the comparison table as "Proposed" since it's speculative, not observed.
- Add references/contact-sheet-method.md with full workflow: grid layout, style blocks, series continuity, Bloom adaptations - Add 'contact-sheet' as new source type in scene metadata - Link reference in the YouTube long-form references section Source: @OriSilver (May 2026)
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 2m 16s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. Five issues found:
The Suno case study, Serialized AI Transformation Pattern, contact sheet method, and Glam Up case study are all good content — they just need to be split into separate PRs with the broken references fixed. See inline comments for specific suggestions. |
| preloaded: true | ||
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
preloaded: true appears twice in the frontmatter (lines 3 and 5). Duplicate YAML keys are undefined behavior — most parsers silently take the last one, but this is a bug. Remove one.
Also, this file is now 303 lines and references 9 files in references/ that don't exist (research.md, hooks.md, hook-variants.md, structures.md, retention.md, retention-data.md, editing.md, algorithm-guide.md, script-template.md). Only contact-sheet-method.md exists. The Long-Form YouTube section added in this PR references all of them — were they meant to be included in this PR?
| preloaded: true | |
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. | |
| preloaded: true | |
| preloaded: true | |
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. |
| --- | ||
| name: content-strategy | ||
| description: "Use when building content strategy: hooks, angles, and ideas from what's trending now. Covers organic and paid creative across TikTok, X, YouTube, Meta, LinkedIn." | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
preloaded: true on a 738-line file means all 738 lines load into the system prompt. The file is already 238 lines over the 500-line SKILL.md limit. This is unrelated to the Suno case study and should be its own PR with justification.
| preloaded: true |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `tweet-ideas` | ||
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | ||
| - Writing articles → `writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → `slideshow-creator` | ||
| - Writing articles → `article-writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or `slideshow-creator`/ReelFarm | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
6 broken skill references. None of these new names exist in the repo:
tweet-ideas→ no SKILL.md (waswriter, which exists)article-writer→ no SKILL.md (waswriter, which exists)slideshow-creator→ no SKILL.md (was "video skills")
Agents following this table will fail to delegate. Revert to the existing skill names.
| - Writing tweets or posts → `tweet-ideas` | |
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | |
| - Writing articles → `writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → `slideshow-creator` | |
| - Writing articles → `article-writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or `slideshow-creator`/ReelFarm | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | |
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | |
| - Writing articles → `writer` | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm |
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research and web-search don't exist as skills. The original had a duplicate last30days (worth fixing) and "web search" (not a backticked skill name). Revert to existing names.
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` | |
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search |
| - Your commentary: explain each label as an investing psychology + content strategy concept simultaneously. Double value for the viewer. | ||
|
|
||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | ||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research doesn't exist. Revert to last30days.
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | |
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or web search to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
| The pattern works because the creator's job is curation (picking the next subject), not creation (inventing a new format). Production cost per episode approaches zero. | ||
|
|
||
| **Why repetition beats variety:** | ||
| - The algorithm rewards predictable quality over creative range | ||
| - Viewers know what to expect, so they return (series architecture) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Bloom column is a hypothetical, not an observed case study like Oasis and Suno. Presenting it in the same table blurs the line. Label it "Bloom (Proposed)" to distinguish observed patterns from ideas.
| The pattern works because the creator's job is curation (picking the next subject), not creation (inventing a new format). Production cost per episode approaches zero. | |
| **Why repetition beats variety:** | |
| - The algorithm rewards predictable quality over creative range | |
| - Viewers know what to expect, so they return (series architecture) | |
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom (Proposed) | | |
| |---------|-------|------|-------| | |
| | Raw material | Water brand | Toxic person's texts | Stock ticker / guru pick / portfolio | | |
| | Transformation | Lab contaminant test | AI song generation | AI analysis / risk score | | |
| | Reveal | Score + contaminants | Song playing over screenshots | Insight card / what AI caught | |
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research and web-search don't exist as skills. The original had a duplicate last30days (worth fixing), but the replacements need to be real skills:
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search` | |
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search |
| - Your commentary: explain each label as an investing psychology + content strategy concept simultaneously. Double value for the viewer. | ||
|
|
||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | ||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
trend-research doesn't exist. Revert to last30days:
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `trend-research` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | |
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or web search to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
| | Reveal | Score + contaminants | Song playing over screenshots | Insight card / what AI caught | | ||
| | Variable per episode | Which brand | Which person / texts | Which ticker / guru / trade | | ||
|
|
||
| The pattern works because the creator's job is curation (picking the next subject), not creation (inventing a new format). Production cost per episode approaches zero. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bloom is a hypothetical, not an observed case study like Oasis and Suno. Label it to distinguish:
| The pattern works because the creator's job is curation (picking the next subject), not creation (inventing a new format). Production cost per episode approaches zero. | |
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom (Proposed) | |
| |-------------|-------| | ||
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | ||
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | | ||
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | ||
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same broken references in the delegation table. Revert to existing skill names:
| |-------------|-------| | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `tweet-ideas` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `article-writer` | | |
| | Tweets / X posts | `writer` | | |
| | Articles / long-form | `writer` | | |
| | TikTok slideshows | video skills | |
| @@ -553,7 +595,7 @@ Don't write here. Route to the right skill. | |||
| | Platform | Tool | | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| | Platform | Tool | | |
| | TikTok | video skills / ReelFarm | |
| ## Related Skills | ||
|
|
||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search, and `character-creation`. | ||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
6 broken skill references. Revert to names that actually exist:
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `tweet-ideas`, `article-writer`, `slideshow-creator`, `content-atomizer`, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `trend-research`, `web-search`, and `character-creation`. | |
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search, and `character-creation`. |
| preloaded: true | ||
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
preloaded: true appears twice (lines 3 and 5). Duplicate YAML keys are undefined behavior — most parsers silently take the last one. Remove one. Also, this 307-line file doesn't need preloaded: true justified in this PR.
| preloaded: true | |
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. | |
| preloaded: true | |
| preloaded: true | |
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts for short-form content (TikTok, Reels, Shorts) and retention-optimized long-form YouTube scripts, with production metadata ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", "long-form video script", "improve video retention", "structure a YouTube video", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", "retention-optimized script", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes or sections with production directions. |
|
|
||
| ### YouTube Long-Form References | ||
|
|
||
| - `references/research.md` — Research & idea development | ||
| - `references/hooks.md` — 9 proven hook formats | ||
| - `references/hook-variants.md` — 5 types with templates and decision guide | ||
| - `references/structures.md` — 7 story structures | ||
| - `references/retention.md` — Retention techniques | ||
| - `references/retention-data.md` — Hard numbers, MrBeast principles | ||
| - `references/editing.md` — Quality audits | ||
| - `references/algorithm-guide.md` — CTR benchmarks, AVD thresholds, signal hierarchy | ||
| - `references/contact-sheet-method.md` — Contact sheet workflow for AI video consistency (character/product locking across shots, style blocks, series continuity, Seedance integration) | ||
| - `references/script-template.md` — Full annotated template with retention risk mapping |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
9 of 10 reference files listed here don't exist. Only contact-sheet-method.md is in the repo. All others are broken paths: research.md, hooks.md, hook-variants.md, structures.md, retention.md, retention-data.md, editing.md, algorithm-guide.md, script-template.md.
Either include these files in the PR or remove the references. As-is, an agent following this skill will try to load files that don't exist.
1. Add Step 2g: Conversion Bridge (views → install → payment) - CTA patterns by format with awareness-level matching - Profile-visit funnel with benchmarks and diagnostics - Discount bounce-back tactic - Comment-as-distribution mechanic 2. Add mandatory research step rule in Purpose section - Every response must include research, even format-focused questions 3. Add synthesis meta-instruction in Purpose section - Pick 2-3 relevant frameworks, don't recite all of them - Strategy output, not framework index
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 1m 50s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. Five blocking issues, one minor:
The Suno case study, Serialized AI Transformation Pattern, contact sheet method, and Glam Up case study are all solid content — they need to be split into separate PRs with broken references fixed. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Blocking Issues
1. 6 broken skill references — content-strategy/SKILL.md
These skill names were introduced in this PR but don't exist anywhere in the repo:
tweet-ideas— no SKILL.md (waswriter, which exists atwriting/writer/SKILL.md)article-writer— no SKILL.md (waswriter)slideshow-creator— no SKILL.md (was "video skills")content-atomizer— no SKILL.md (new, no prior equivalent)trend-research— no SKILL.md (was duplicatelast30days, which exists)web-search— no SKILL.md (was "web search", unbackticked)
Broken at 8 locations: lines 15, 18, 19, 20, 44, 483, 634-636, 651, 796. Agents routing via these names will fail silently. Revert to existing names (writer, last30days, video skills, web search) or create the skills first in a separate PR.
2. Duplicate preloaded: true — video-script/SKILL.md
preloaded: true appears on both line 3 and line 5 of the frontmatter. Duplicate YAML keys are undefined behavior. Remove one.
3. 9 broken reference file paths — video-script/SKILL.md
The Long-Form YouTube section (lines 295-307) lists 10 reference files. Only contact-sheet-method.md exists. These 9 are broken: research.md, hooks.md, hook-variants.md, structures.md, retention.md, retention-data.md, editing.md, algorithm-guide.md, script-template.md. Either include them or remove the references.
4. Scope creep
PR title says "add Suno AI case study" but bundles 6 distinct changes:
- Suno case study + Serialized AI Transformation Pattern (content-strategy)
- Glam Up case study + Referral-as-Gate section (content-strategy, 177-line reference file)
- Contact sheet method (video-script, 136-line reference file)
- Long-form YouTube scriptwriting section (video-script, ~85 lines)
preloaded: trueadded to both files- 6+ skill renames across content-strategy
Per repo conventions: "One logical change per PR. Don't stack unrelated changes."
5. File length — content-strategy/SKILL.md
796 lines, up from 701 on main. Already 201 lines over the 500-line SKILL.md limit before this PR. Adding preloaded: true pushes all 796 lines into the system prompt. Either move content to references/ to get under 500 or drop preloaded: true.
Minor
6. Bloom column in comparison table (line 532): Bloom is a hypothetical, not an observed case study like Oasis and Suno. Label it "Bloom (Proposed)" to distinguish.
Recommended path forward
- Revert all skill renames to existing names (
writer,last30days, video skills, web search). - Remove
preloaded: truefrom both files (or justify in a separate PR). - Fix the duplicate
preloaded: truein video-script frontmatter. - Either include the 9 missing reference files or remove the broken paths.
- Split into separate PRs: (a) Suno case study, (b) Glam Up case study, (c) video-script long-form + contact sheet.
- Label the Bloom column as "Bloom (Proposed)".
…frontmatter - Fix 6 broken skill references: tweet-ideas→writer, article-writer→writer, slideshow-creator→removed, content-atomizer→removed, trend-research→last30days, web-search→grok-search - Reduce SKILL.md from 796→340 lines (limit: 500) by moving sections to references: viral-breakdown-pillar.md, result-first-proof-loop.md, repeatable-daily-format.md, conversion-bridge.md - Remove duplicate preloaded: true in video-script frontmatter - Merge duplicate routing rows in Step 3 table
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 3m 15s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. The fix commit (66828a3) addressed many earlier issues — broken skill references are reverted, duplicate
Minor: Bloom column in the comparison table should be labeled "Bloom (Proposed)" since it's speculative. |
| - `references/research.md` — Research & idea development | ||
| - `references/hooks.md` — 9 proven hook formats | ||
| - `references/hook-variants.md` — 5 types with templates and decision guide | ||
| - `references/structures.md` — 7 story structures | ||
| - `references/retention.md` — Retention techniques | ||
| - `references/retention-data.md` — Hard numbers, MrBeast principles | ||
| - `references/editing.md` — Quality audits | ||
| - `references/algorithm-guide.md` — CTR benchmarks, AVD thresholds, signal hierarchy | ||
| - `references/contact-sheet-method.md` — Contact sheet workflow for AI video consistency (character/product locking across shots, style blocks, series continuity, Seedance integration) | ||
| - `references/script-template.md` — Full annotated template with retention risk mapping |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
9 of 10 reference files listed here don't exist. Only contact-sheet-method.md is in the repo. The missing files are: research.md, hooks.md, hook-variants.md, structures.md, retention.md, retention-data.md, editing.md, algorithm-guide.md, script-template.md.
The Long-Form YouTube section also references these inline (lines 241, 244, 247, 259). An agent following this skill will try to load files that don't exist.
Either include these files in the PR or remove the references and the Long-Form YouTube section.
|
|
||
| Formula: `[raw material with built-in curiosity] + [AI/tool transformation] + [serial numbering] = compounding series` | ||
|
|
||
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Bloom column presents speculative format candidates alongside observed case studies (Oasis, Suno). Label it "Bloom (Proposed)" to distinguish.
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom | | |
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom (Proposed) | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | ||
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | ||
| - Generating images → `nano-banana-pro` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
nano-banana-pro doesn't have a SKILL.md in this repo — it exists only as scripts referenced by other skills. On main this line said image-generator or nano-banana-pro (neither exists as a skill). Not a regression from this PR, but worth noting this is still a broken reference.
If there's no image-generation skill to route to, consider dropping this line or saying "image generation tools" without backtick-quoting a nonexistent skill name.
| --- | ||
| name: video-script | ||
| description: Generate structured scene-by-scene video scripts with production metadata (visuals, audio, sources, transitions, captions) ready to feed into the video-production pipeline (Sora, Kling, ElevenLabs, InfiniteTalk, Remotion, stock-footage, video-editor). Use when asked to "write a video script", "script for TikTok", "video outline", "plan a video", "storyboard", "scene breakdown", "video concept", "content brief for video", "shooting script", or whenever the video-production pipeline needs a structured script before production begins. Also trigger for "Reels script", "Shorts script", "YouTube script", "video idea with scenes", or any request that implies breaking a video concept into timed scenes with production directions. | ||
| preloaded: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
preloaded: true was added to this file as part of this PR but isn't mentioned in the PR description. This file went from 205→306 lines, so preloading pushes 306 lines into the system prompt. Consider whether this is intentional and justified — it's unrelated to the Suno case study.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
What the fix commit addressed
Commit 66828a3 fixed many issues from prior reviews: broken skill references (reverted to writer, last30days, etc.), duplicate preloaded: true in video-script, removed preloaded: true from content-strategy, and reduced SKILL.md from 796→340 lines by extracting sections to references. Good progress.
Remaining blocking issues
1. 9 broken reference file paths — video/video-script/SKILL.md
The Long-Form YouTube section (lines 225-306) references 9 files in references/ that don't exist: research.md, hooks.md, hook-variants.md, structures.md, retention.md, retention-data.md, editing.md, algorithm-guide.md, script-template.md. Only contact-sheet-method.md exists. These are referenced both inline (lines 241, 244, 247, 259) and in the references list (lines 297-306). An agent following this skill will try to load nonexistent files.
2. Scope creep — still 4+ distinct changes
The fix commit reduced scope but the PR still bundles:
- Suno case study + Serialized AI Transformation Pattern (content-strategy)
- Glam Up case study (177-line reference file) + Referral-as-Gate section
- Contact sheet method (136-line reference file) + Long-form YouTube scriptwriting (~85 lines) in video-script
preloaded: trueadded to video-script- Content-strategy SKILL.md restructuring (significant condensation + new sections like 2g Conversion Bridge)
Per repo conventions: "One logical change per PR."
3. Content deleted without relocation
The condensation to get under 500 lines dropped several sections from content-strategy/SKILL.md that were NOT moved to reference files:
- "Sell the Big Picture, Then the Small Action"
- "Reader-First Reframe"
- "Open Loops" / "Curiosity Gap"
- "The Hands-Doing-Something Format" (full subsection with structure and examples)
- "Pre-Posting Creative QA Loop" (detailed workflow with Higgsfield integration)
- "Weekly Creator Review" (creator program management)
- "Hook Evolution Loop"
Some of these (Open Loops, Curiosity Gap) overlap with existing reference content, but others (Pre-Posting Creative QA, Weekly Creator Review, Hands-Doing-Something) are unique content that's now lost.
Minor
4. Bloom column labeling: The Bloom column in the Serialized AI Transformation Pattern table (repeatable-daily-format.md line 22) is speculative. Label it "Bloom (Proposed)" to distinguish from observed case studies.
5. nano-banana-pro reference (content-strategy/SKILL.md line 20): Not a regression (main had the same issue), but nano-banana-pro has no SKILL.md in the repo.
Recommended path forward
- Either include the 9 missing reference files for video-script or remove the Long-Form YouTube section from this PR (split to its own PR with the files).
- Move the deleted content-strategy sections to reference files before removing them from SKILL.md, or acknowledge the deletions are intentional.
- Split the Glam Up case study, contact sheet method, and video-script changes into separate PRs.
- Label the Bloom column as "Bloom (Proposed)".
- content-strategy SKILL.md: 796 → 510 lines (under 500 limit) - Move Step 2b, 2d, 2f, 2g, Step 5, geo-targeting to reference files - Each section retains inline summary + load-on-demand link - Fix 6 broken skill references (tweet-ideas, article-writer, etc) - Remove preloaded: true (runtime-only config) - video-script SKILL.md: revert to main + add only targeted additions - Remove long-form YouTube section (scope creep, had 9 broken refs) - Keep: emotional transformation style, contact-sheet source type - Fix duplicate preloaded: true - New reference files: analyze-optimize, pre-creator-validation - Updated reference files: conversion-bridge, repeatable-daily-format, viral-breakdown-pillar (re-extracted with full content)
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 2m 44s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryRequested changes. The fix commits (66828a3, f4e53e1) addressed most prior blockers — broken skill references reverted,
All three have inline comments with code suggestions. |
| | TikTok accounts with <1k followers | Viral signals before algo amplification; comment sentiment on what's actually resonating | | ||
|
|
||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search | ||
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `grok-search` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The fix commit replaced the duplicate last30days with a duplicate grok-search. Should be three distinct skills:
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, `grok-search` | |
| **Skills to use:** `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search |
| ## Related Skills | ||
|
|
||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `last30days`, web search, and `character-creation`. | ||
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, slideshow tools, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `grok-search`, and `character-creation`. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Two duplicate pairs here: writer appears twice and grok-search appears twice. Also, slideshow tools isn't a skill name (main had video skills which also isn't a backticked skill — both are informal references, but this is a gratuitous rename).
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, `writer`, slideshow tools, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, `grok-search`, and `character-creation`. | |
| Use adjacent skills as needed: `hooks`, `copywriting`, `writer`, video skills, `typefully`, `last30days`, `grok-search`, web search, and `character-creation`. |
| - Labels you'd drop: "LOSS AVERSION" (the emotional hook), "ROUND NUMBER" (they lost exactly $10K, not $9,847), "SCREENSHOT FORMAT" (looks organic, not produced), "NO CTA" (the virality IS the content, no ask) | ||
| - Your commentary: explain each label as an investing psychology + content strategy concept simultaneously. Double value for the viewer. | ||
|
|
||
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Duplicate last30days carried over from main — this was the bug the fix commit was supposed to address:
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or `last30days` to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). | |
| **Sourcing:** Use `last30days`, `grok-search`, or web search to find viral posts in the investing/personal finance niche weekly. Look for 50K+ views, especially from accounts under 10K followers (pre-algo signal). |
|
|
||
| Formula: `[raw material with built-in curiosity] + [AI/tool transformation] + [serial numbering] = compounding series` | ||
|
|
||
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Prior reviews flagged this: Bloom is a hypothetical format candidate, not an observed case study like Oasis and Suno. Label it to distinguish:
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom | | |
| | Element | Oasis | Suno | Bloom (Proposed) | |
| - Writing tweets or posts → `writer` | ||
| - Generating images → `image-generator` or `nano-banana-pro` | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills | ||
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → slideshow tools |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
video skills was renamed to slideshow tools across the file, but neither is a real skill name — there's no slideshow-creator or slideshow-tools SKILL.md in the repo. The main branch used video skills consistently. This rename is unrelated to the Suno case study and changes 5 locations for no functional benefit. Revert to video skills to match main:
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → slideshow tools | |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → video skills |
| - Creating TikTok slideshows → slideshow tools | ||
| - Writing articles → `writer` | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm | ||
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or slideshow tools/ReelFarm |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or slideshow tools/ReelFarm | |
| - Scheduling → `typefully` or video skills/ReelFarm |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Good progress on fix commits — 3 issues remain
The fix commits (66828a3, f4e53e1) addressed the major blockers from prior reviews: broken skill references reverted, preloaded: true removed from both files, duplicate frontmatter fixed, and SKILL.md condensed from 701→510 lines (close to the 500-line limit). Content was properly relocated to reference files. Solid work.
Remaining issues
1. Duplicate skill references (3 locations)
The fix commit that removed duplicate last30days introduced new duplicates:
SKILL.md:43—grok-searchappears twice (was:last30daystwice on main)SKILL.md:510—writerappears twice ANDgrok-searchappears twicereferences/viral-breakdown-pillar.md:32—last30daysappears twice (carried over from main, never fixed)
See inline comments for suggested fixes.
2. Gratuitous "video skills" → "slideshow tools" rename (5 locations)
video skills was renamed to slideshow tools across content-strategy/SKILL.md (lines 21, 23, 458, 472). Neither is a backticked skill name, but "video skills" was the consistent convention on main. No slideshow-tools or slideshow-creator skill exists. This rename is unrelated to the Suno case study and should be reverted to match main.
3. Bloom column labeling in comparison table
references/repeatable-daily-format.md:20 — the Bloom column in the Serialized AI Transformation Pattern table is speculative, not observed like Oasis and Suno. Label it "Bloom (Proposed)".
Scope note
The fix commits significantly narrowed scope. The PR now primarily contains: (a) Suno case study + Serialized AI Transformation Pattern, (b) content-strategy restructuring (extracting sections to reference files), (c) Glam Up case study reference, (d) contact-sheet method + emotional transformation format in video-script. Items (a) and (b) are tightly coupled. Items (c) and (d) are still separate logical changes — consider splitting into follow-up PRs, but this is no longer blocking.
File length
SKILL.md is 510 lines — 10 over the 500-line limit. The restructuring brought it close; trimming the duplicate references and removing one or two verbose lines would get it under.
- Remove duplicate grok-search and last30days references - Revert slideshow tools → video skills to match main - Remove duplicate writer reference - Label Bloom column as (Proposed) in comparison table
|
Claude finished @exiao's task in 2m 53s —— View job Reviewing PR #149
SummaryApproved. The fix commits (66828a3, f4e53e1, ff478bd) resolved all prior blocking issues:
Non-blocking: |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The fix commits (66828a3, f4e53e1, ff478bd) addressed all prior blocking issues:
- Broken skill references: All 6 broken names (
tweet-ideas,article-writer,slideshow-creator,content-atomizer,trend-research,web-search) reverted to existing names (writer,last30days,grok-search, video skills, web search). Verified via grep — zero broken references remain. - Duplicate references: Fixed.
last30daysno longer duplicated in SKILL.md orviral-breakdown-pillar.md.grok-searchandwriterno longer duplicated in Related Skills. preloaded: true: Removed from both files. No duplicate YAML keys.- "slideshow tools" → "video skills": Reverted to match main.
- Bloom (Proposed) label: Added in comparison table (
repeatable-daily-format.md:20). - File length: SKILL.md reduced from 701 (main) to 510 lines. Content properly relocated to 7 new reference files that all exist and contain the full extracted sections (Pre-Posting QA Loop, Weekly Creator Review, Hook Evolution Loop, etc.).
- video-script changes: Minimal (5 lines added to SKILL.md +
contact-sheet-method.mdreference file). No broken references — the 9 nonexistent reference files from earlier commits were removed.
Scope note: The PR still bundles the Suno case study with the Glam Up case study, contact sheet method, content-strategy restructuring, and video-script additions. Strictly, repo conventions say "one logical change per PR." However, the restructuring (extracting sections to reference files) was required to accommodate the new content within the 500-line limit, and the Suno/Glam Up case studies are thematically related (both feed into the Serialized AI Transformation Pattern). The video-script changes (5 lines + 1 reference file) are the most separable piece but are small enough that splitting would be churn. Acceptable as-is.
Minor (non-blocking): nano-banana-pro on line 20 is not a standalone skill (no SKILL.md at that path), but this is pre-existing from main, not introduced by this PR.
1 participant
Summary
Add the Suno AI "turning texts into songs" case study to the content-strategy skill's Repeatable Daily Format section (Step 2f), and extract a generalized Serialized AI Transformation Pattern from the Oasis + Suno cases.
Source: @alexolim_ tweet (May 2026)
Changes