Discussion_instructions

Discussion instructions

colloquium instructions:

• eMail the colloquium speaker, and ask for the paper dat will most closely discuss the colloquium's content.
• Find another paper that criticises the work, or discuss it in a different context.
• Read the paper
• Prepare a 10 minutes presentation about the paper
• In the discussion you will raise 3 questions:
  • One questions either on metholodogy or approach.
  • One questions either on future prospects.
  • One questions either on alternative explanations/models/theory.

Role of the chair

• read the three papers two of which are part of the discussion, one is part of the colloquium.
• discuss with the two presenters what they think is the key aspect of their respective papers.
• Juxtapose the two objectives of the two papers.
• Think of 3 questions you would like to have addressed during the time you discuss the papers.

Paper discussions

• Read the paper
• Prepare a 10 minutes presentation about the paper
• Find one paper that criticises the work, or that discuss it in a different context.
• In the discussion you will raise 3 questions:
  • One questions either on metholodogy or approach.
  • One questions either on future prospects.
  • One questions either on alternative explanations/models/theory.