Skip to content

docs: add PR reviewer evidence checklist (#163) - #190

Merged
El-swaggerito merged 1 commit into
zionvera:mainfrom
fredericjasmin:feature/issue-163-pr-reviewer-evidence-checklist
Jul 29, 2026
Merged

docs: add PR reviewer evidence checklist (#163)#190
El-swaggerito merged 1 commit into
zionvera:mainfrom
fredericjasmin:feature/issue-163-pr-reviewer-evidence-checklist

Conversation

@fredericjasmin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Closes #163

Adds a concise PR reviewer evidence checklist for AnchorKit maintainers. The checklist provides a central reference for reviewing implementation scope, implementation quality, test evidence, CI status, documentation impact, acceptance criteria, and implementation risk while linking to the existing canonical documentation instead of duplicating guidance.

Issue scope

Acceptance Criterion Status Implementation Evidence Tests Notes
Reviewer evidence checklist is added. ✅ Completed Added docs/REVIEWER_EVIDENCE_CHECKLIST.md. N/A (documentation) Central reviewer reference.
Implementation scope is checked. ✅ Completed Checklist includes implementation scope verification. N/A References existing review guidance.
Test evidence is checked. ✅ Completed Checklist references existing testing evidence documentation. N/A
CI status is checked. ✅ Completed Checklist references existing CI guidance. N/A
Acceptance criteria are checked. ✅ Completed Checklist references acceptance criteria documentation. N/A
README links to reviewer guidance. ✅ Completed Added the new checklist to the README documentation index. N/A

Affected packages / apps

  • apps/web
  • packages/types
  • packages/config
  • packages/fixtures
  • packages/validators
  • packages/stellar-kit
  • packages/anchor-utils
  • contracts/treasury-escrow
  • docs/
  • Other (list):

Testing performed

Commands executed:

  • pnpm test ✅ Passed (all TypeScript tests passed)
  • pnpm verify ⚠️ Could not complete successfully because the Rust cargo toolchain is unavailable in the current environment. Remaining reported issues are pre-existing and unrelated to this documentation-only change.

This PR only introduces documentation changes and does not modify runtime behavior.

Screenshots / recordings

N/A

Security impact

  • No security-relevant surface touched.

Documentation impact

  • Docs under /docs updated for this change.
  • README updated.
  • No user-facing behaviour changed — no docs update needed.

Maintainer Review Checklist (self-check)

PR self-check

  • References the original issue with Closes #163 in the PR body.
  • Acceptance criteria on the issue are checked off individually in the PR description.
  • pnpm verify passes locally (Rust toolchain unavailable in the current environment).
  • pnpm check:boundaries passes locally (not applicable for this documentation-only change).
  • pnpm contract:test passes locally (not applicable).

Stellar network correctness

Not applicable.

Anchor and SEP flow correctness

Not applicable.

Payment intent and readiness correctness

Not applicable.

Soroban contract correctness (if contracts/ changed)

Not applicable.

Secret leakage (R0–R6)

Not applicable.

Mainnet safety

Not applicable.

Tests

Not applicable (documentation-only change).

Documentation

  • Topic docs updated.
  • README docs index updated.
  • Security docs updated if new threat areas introduced.

Risk / follow-ups

None.

Acceptance Criteria Audit

All acceptance criteria for Issue #163 have been completed.

GrantFox payment expectations

Acknowledged.

Contributor self-review

Documentation-only change with a minimal diff. The implementation adds a reviewer evidence checklist, updates the README documentation index, reuses existing documentation instead of duplicating guidance, and does not change application behavior.

@El-swaggerito
El-swaggerito merged commit 8d8df41 into zionvera:main Jul 29, 2026
1 check passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Add AnchorKit PR reviewer evidence checklist

2 participants